VIRGINIA STAGE COMPANY: ALWAYS… PATSY CLINE :THE TROUBADOUR AS HERO

The March 7, 1963 headlines blazoned the news across the front page of the Los Angeles Times:

Three ‘Grand Old Opry’ Stars Die in Air Crash. Bodies of Patsy Cline, Hankshaw Hawkins and Cowboy Copas Found on Tennessee Hill.

And it happened just four years after another plane crash took the lives of Buddy Holly, Richie Valens, and J.P. “The Big Bopper” Richardson.

Patsy Cline’s career had lasted a mere six years: from her debut in 1957 until her death at the age of 30.

But there was something about the singer and her songs to cause her to become the first woman inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame ten years later; the first female country singer to tour as a lead act; the first female country singer to headline in Las Vegas; and the first female country singer to perform at Carnegie Hall.

That Patsy Cline “something” propelled Jessica Lange to an Academy Award nomination for her portrayal of Patsy Cline in 1986’s Sweet Dreams. Two years later Ted Swindley’s Always…Patsy Cline premiered, and hasn’t stopped yet.

Patsy Cline is memorialized in the Country Music Hall of Fame as

the most popular female country singer in recording history, Cline is invariably invoked as a standard for female vocalists, and she has inspired scores of singers including k. d. lang, Loretta Lynn, Linda Ronstadt, Trisha Yearwood, and Wynonna Judd. Her brief career produced the #1 jukebox hit of all time, “Crazy” (written by Willie Nelson) and her unique, crying style and vocal impeccability have established her reputation as the quintessential torch singer.”

 The Virginia Stage Company’s production of Always… Patsy Cline is ““a jukebox musical based on the true story of Patsy Cline’s friendship with a Houston housewife named Louise Seger, her most devoted fan.”

After explaining the backstory of her devotion to the singer, the character of Louise narrates the story of the day in 1961 when she met Patsy Cline at Houston’s Esquire Ballroom. After this meeting, the singer keeps in touch with Louise by writing her long handwritten letters until the day she dies.  She signs the letters “(Love) Always, Patsy Cline.”

That’s the musical drama.

Today our heroes are not warriors. Today’s youngsters don’t dream of their first sword or rifle. Achilles, Prince Hal, Eleanor of Aquitaine, Saint Joan, Major Barbara, Catherine the Great, and El Cid are unknown.

Instead our youngsters yearn for their first guitar. Everyone records their personal epics for You Tube. Musicians dictate fashion as well as political opinion.

Today our bards sing hymns, not of warriors, but  songs of themselves. Our heroes are troubadours. The musicians who once sang of the hero’s exploits, are now the heroes themselves. As protagonists, they, unlike their historical predecessors, face no antagonists. Today’s Othello doesn’t have to deal with a contemporary Iago. Today’s Jean Val Jean has no Javert to fear.

As the late great American critic Albert Bermel noted, today’s heroes are psychologically conceived and realized. The modern hero suffers, not because of an external antagonist, but

“because of an inner conflict. Today’s protagonist cannot reconcile the warring impulses from his unconscious. The very conflict in him, that confusion of fears and desires, makes the fears come true. He himself brings to pass what he most dreads, He finally undergoes the losses he had only imagined, and he has only himself to blame.”[i]

The contemporary musician fits Bermel’s bill like no other, as he chronicles every impulse, every desire, every conflict for the world to hear.

Patsy Cline, like Buddy Holly, Johnny Cash, Frankie Valli, Janis Joplin, Tina Turner and other “jukebox” stage heroes, epitomizes the musician as hero. Every title of a Cline song represents a scene in the dramatic arc of her life riding the “Honky Tonk Merry Go Round”

The Virginia Stage Company’s production of Always, Patsy Cline is such a monumentally popular and emotionally satisfying experience that the producers should be calling empty Norfolk theaters, like the Riverside, to arrange a transfer of the show, after the Wells Theatre run, so that every man, woman, and child of Virginia might attend this glorious tribute to one of their own.

The success begins with stage and musical director Amy Jones. She obviously connects with this material in ways she didn’t in last year’s project – Ring of Fire. Every musician, actor, and designer is  first rate, perfect for what Ms. Jones asks them to do.

Linda Edwards plays one of the most difficult type of roles any actor can be called upon to play – the Narrator. She succeeds so well that she makes what she does look easy, the mark of a true artist. Her Louise Seger is what my father would call “the salt of the earth”, a “down to earth” “good egg”. She presents a personality each of us have encountered at least once in our lives, and establishes a strong bond of trust, pleasure, and expectation with each member of the audience. And if that isn’t enough, she can sing as well.

Of all the iconic country musicians Patsy Cline was the most enigmatic. She seemed to live in a zone of her own creation and to phrase particular sounds with a uniqueness which cut to a listener’s very being. (Her rendition of the first phrase of her magnificent “I Fall to Pieces” is a Rorschach test of a person’s very humanity. It can rattle one’s soul.)

Somehow Sandia Ahlers creates, or perhaps channels, that peculiar Patsy Cline magic. She finds a way into and, once there, remains in Cline’s distinctive performing zone, while revealing her evolving character almost exclusively through song. The performance climaxes with “Crazy” sung at Louise’s kitchen table. In Ms. Ahlers hands, as directed by Ms. Jones, the song becomes a dazzling American folk opera verismo aria.

The whole thing is staged on veteran scene designer Dennis Maulden’s lovely functional and flexible concert stage unit setting. Mr. Maulden knows this musical doesn’t need a setting fighting with the music for attention and so his work imaginatively provides a showcase for the musicians’ excellence. The Virginia Stage Company’s resident costumer designer, Jeni Schaefer, turns in one of her most successful efforts. Ms. Cline’s frequent changes are appropriate not only to character but to the show’s variety of times and places. B. Butterbaugh’s lighting subtly follows the emotional keys as they ebb and flow, across and around, the multileveled stage. The sound provided by designer Steven Allegretto is perfectly amplified, blended and modulated throughout.

Always, Patsy Cline demonstrates that friendship need not end with death. Rather, friendship cherished, like that between Patsy and Louise, can grow and spread, delighting thousands along the way.

[i] Albert Bermel. Contradictory Characters. An Interpretation of the Modern Theatre. New York:  E.P.Dutton and Co., Inc, 1973.


TOI’s HANSEL AND GRETEL: BEAUTIFUL AND FUN AND UNIVERSALLY TRUE

Why a fairy tale? A fairy tale explains the world to both youngsters and to adults, who may have forgotten important truths. As the fairy tale master Bruno Bettelheim explains, the fairy tale expresses in words and actions the things which go on in the child’s, or childlike adult, mind. Or as G.K. Chesterton rightly […]


MET OPERA’S EUGENE ONEGIN: TCHAIKOVSKY’S MASTERPIECE

Tchaikovsky didn’t care if his new opera was any good. You may well be right in saying that my opera, [Eugene Onegin], will not be effective on the stage…I have no dramatic vein, and now I don’t worry about it…I wrote this opera because I was moved one day with the unutterable force to express […]


LA SCALA’S GIOVANNA D’ARCO: When an Opera is a Lie

As of 2009, ten percent of Americans thought Joan of Arc was Noah’s wife.[i] Since then most people probably won’t even guess as to her identity. And where could they learn of Joan of Arc? Schools, where any hint of Christianity is outlawed? In mainline churches, where scientific rationalism filters the majesty and mystery of […]


THE MET OPERA’S IL TROVATORE: THE TRAGEDY OF VENGEANCE

Giuseppe Verdi’s Il Trovatore is probably best known as the center of the Marx Brothers great film comedy A Night at the Opera. Ridicule, parody, burlesque and satire have followed the opera almost even from composition. Based on the classic Spanish Romantic drama El Trovador by Antonio Garcia Gutiérrez, librettist Salvadore Cammarano sent Verdi a […]


THE MET’S MADAMA BUTTERFLY: THE POWER OF UNIVERSALS

The most recent study names Puccini’s Madama Butterfly as the sixth most popular opera in the world. In fact, seeing the opera at the age of sixteen prompted Yoko Watanabe (1953-2004) to a singing career, eventually to the position of the most famous of Japanese opera singers, certainly to be one of the most acclaimed […]


TIDEWATER STAGE’S DIAL M FOR MURDER: FABULOUS THEATER

“Smell-o-vision” “Illusion-o” “Percepto” “Sensurround” “3D” The history of film can be seen as an ongoing attempt to use technology to reproduce and distribute the power of live stage performance inexpensively to a wide audience. Before considering the work at Tidewater Stage, let’s look at the journey Frederick’s Knott’s tale took to get to Virginia Beach. […]


Virginia Stage Company’s CROWNS: A Majestic Theater Event

In his first letter to the Thessalonians, Saint Paul asked, For what is our hope or joy or crown of boasting before our Lord Jesus at his coming? Is it not you? Saint John Chrysostom explained that, ”he who will not seek in the well being of his neighbor his own benefit will not attain […]


CHICAGO SHAKESPEARE’S MACBETH: Imagination’s Descent into Hell

 Viewed in the context of his other work, Macbeth is Shakespeare’s Descent into Hell. And since it is his Inferno, it is appropriate that the terrestrial and celestial parts of his universe should figure slightly.[i] Those words by University of Chicago Shakespearean scholar Harold Goddard summarize the production Aaron Posner and Teller have created at […]


AMERICAN BLUES THEATER: BUDDY HOLLY LIVES

Buddy Holly was my favorite rock and roller and first hero. As an eight year old boy with a single bud headphone from his transistor radio I waited for Buddy’s music to come on after I went to bed. We shared a common trait  – glasses. In the days before contact lenses, we “four-eyes” were […]